Could Joanna Gaines’ Paint Alternative Bring More Character To Your Modern Home?
AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

TL;DR

Joanna Gaines used matte black walls in an industrial loft featured in Season 5, Episode 16 of Fixer Upper, balancing the dark color with white trim and lighter furnishings. The example makes black an alternative to beige, though its effect depends on room size, light and how it is used.

Joanna Gaines used matte black paint on the walls of an industrial loft featured in Fixer Upper Season 5, Episode 16, presenting the dark shade as an alternative to neutral wall colors. The design paired the black walls with white trim and light flooring, illustrating how contrast can keep a bold color from dominating a room.

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime

  • Fast, free delivery on millions of items
  • Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
  • Member-only deals all year
Start your free Prime trial Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Gaines described the loft design in a post on Magnolia, saying the team used matte black on the walls and balanced it with the room’s flooring, rug and furniture. The styling makes the paint choice part of a broader palette rather than an isolated statement. The episode is one example of Gaines using black, a departure from the airy colors often associated with her modern farmhouse projects.

Other Fixer Upper projects cited in the Magnolia material use the color on a smaller scale. In Season 3, Episode 4, Gaines added black paint to lower kitchen cabinets in a space she described as wide open and light. In episode 8 of Fixer Upper: Welcome Home, black appears on woodwork and door and window trim, rather than across the walls.

The examples suggest several ways to use the shade: cover walls in a room with balancing light elements, apply it to cabinetry, or use it as trim against a neutral wall. They do not establish that black will suit every home. Dark paint can absorb light and make a room feel more enclosed, so the effect depends on the room and its existing finishes.

At a glance
reportWhen: The design appeared in Fixer Upper Seas…
The developmentA Fixer Upper episode and Magnolia blog post show Joanna Gaines using matte black paint in a loft and describe ways to balance the dark color.
Interior design · Briefing

Could Black Paint Bring More Character? Joanna Gaines’ Loft Example

Matte black walls can add contrast and modern character. Their effect depends on room light, size and surrounding finishes.

Three ways to use black

Gaines’ projects show how the same shade can make a bold statement or a smaller accent.

Walls

Make a bold statement

In the industrial loft, lighter flooring, white trim and furnishings balanced the matte black walls.

Cabinets

Add contrast below

Black lower kitchen cabinets brought contrast to a wide-open, light space.

Trim

Start with details

Black woodwork and door and window trim offer a smaller-scale option against neutral walls.

What changes the effect

Dark paint absorbs light, so consider the room and its existing finishes.

Can help
  • Lighter floors, trim and furnishings balance dark walls.
  • A smaller area can introduce black with less commitment.
May feel enclosed
  • Low available light can make black feel heavier.
  • Room size, windows and nearby colors affect the result.

Try the look thoughtfully

Test the shade in the actual room before choosing how much to paint.

1
Choose the scope

Decide between walls, lower cabinets or trim.

2
Check it in place

Compare samples at different times of day to see how light changes the color.

3
Balance the palette

For a stronger wall treatment, pair black with lighter finishes and furnishings.

Paint matchMagnolia suggests Off-Black by Farrow & Ball as a close match, but does not confirm it was used in the loft.
Key pointBlack paint can add character, but test it in your room because light and finishes shape the result.
The takeaway
Use black where it suits your space, and balance its depth with the room’s light and finishes.

How Black Changes a Room

Black offers homeowners a way to add contrast and a more modern character without relying on a bright accent color. In Gaines’ loft, light floors, white trim and furnishings helped offset the dark walls, while the cabinet and trim examples show that the same color can be used without painting an entire room.

The choice also involves a practical trade-off. Because dark colors absorb light, black may make some rooms feel smaller or more enclosed. That can be a deliberate effect in a small room where a cozy, cocoon-like atmosphere is wanted, but it may not be suitable for someone seeking a brighter, more open feel. Testing the shade in the actual space and considering available light and surrounding materials can help homeowners judge the result before committing.

Products Worth Considering

Shark Pet Cordless Stick Vacuum, Up to 40-Minute Runtime, Grey, IX141

Shark Pet Cordless Stick Vacuum, Up to 40-Minute Runtime, Grey, IX141

Blueair 2-in-1 Air Purifier and Humidifier for Rooms up to 1,726 sq. ft.

Blueair 2-in-1 Air Purifier and Humidifier for Rooms up to 1,726 sq. ft.

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.

Black Across Gaines’ Projects

The loft is presented as a departure from the light palettes often associated with Gaines’ modern farmhouse style. It is not her only recorded use of black: Magnolia’s descriptions also point to lower kitchen cabinets in one Fixer Upper episode and black trim in Fixer Upper: Welcome Home. Across those projects, the color shifts from a wall treatment to a more contained detail.

For homeowners interested in a similar look, the Magnolia material identifies Off-Black by Farrow & Ball as a close match to the loft’s paint. It describes the shade as having a chalky pigment that can feel less harsh. That reference is a suggested match, not confirmation of the exact product used on the television project. A lower-commitment option is to use black on trim against a neutral wall.

What the Examples Do Not Show

The available descriptions do not specify the exact paint product or color formula used on the loft walls, nor do they provide measurements, lighting conditions or before-and-after data. The suggestion that Farrow & Ball’s Off-Black is a close match is not a confirmation that Gaines used that product.

It is also unclear how the finish would look in different homes. Room dimensions, window placement, artificial lighting and nearby colors all affect how dark paint reads. The examples offer design approaches, not a guarantee that black walls will make a particular room feel balanced or more modern.

Ways to Test the Look

There is no announced follow-up project or product tied to the loft design. For readers considering the look, the next step is to decide how much black to introduce: full walls, lower cabinets or trim. Comparing paint samples in the room at different times of day can help show how available light changes the color.

Homeowners who are unsure about a full wall treatment can begin with a smaller area or use black trim against a neutral wall. Those who want the loft’s stronger effect can pair dark walls with lighter flooring, trim and furnishings, as Gaines described. The final result will depend on the room’s own light and finishes.

Key Questions

Where did Joanna Gaines use matte black wall paint?

Gaines used it in an industrial loft featured in Fixer Upper Season 5, Episode 16. She said the design balanced the walls with lighter flooring, a rug and furniture.

Does black paint make a room feel smaller?

It can. Dark colors absorb light, which may make a room feel more enclosed. The result depends on the room’s size, natural light and surrounding finishes.

How can I try black without painting all the walls?

Use it on lower cabinets, door and window trim, or other woodwork. Magnolia’s examples include both black kitchen cabinets and black trim.

Which paint shade is suggested as a close match?

The Magnolia material identifies Off-Black by Farrow & Ball as a close match to the loft color. It does not confirm that this was the product used in the episode.

Source: hunker.com

You May Also Like

Chic Living Room Color Combos to Try Now

Transform your space with our top picks for chic colour combination for living room that will elevate your home’s style.

A “Very Early 2000S” Kitchen Got A Bold, Purple Redo (With A Disco Ball!)

Nate Klass refreshed his kitchen with purple paint, new backsplash tile and a disco ball, keeping the existing layout and most of the cabinetry.

Trendsetting Interior Paint Colors for 2025: Insights Into the Top Paint Colors Predicted for the Year

Awaken your home’s potential with the trendsetting paint colors of 2025, featuring earthy tones and jewel hues that will transform your space beautifully.

Green and Beige Bedroom Color Scheme

Discover how a green and beige bedroom color scheme can transform your space into a serene oasis that invites relaxation and harmony.