TL;DR
VERANDA asked designers who subscribe to its Trade Secrets newsletter which kitchen design ideas they are ready to move on from. The responses include double islands, pot fillers, accent backsplashes and open shelving, but the article presents professional preferences—not a consensus or proof that these choices are outdated for every home.
VERANDA asked designers who subscribe to its Trade Secrets newsletter to identify kitchen design ideas they are ready to leave behind, publishing a list of 13 features for homeowners planning a build or renovation. The responses criticize choices including double islands, pot fillers and open shelving, but reflect the views of the designers surveyed rather than a measured industry-wide shift.
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The designers’ objections range from practical concerns to questions of style. Northern California designer Lisa Simopoulos said double islands can make movement through a kitchen awkward and argued that most homes lack the space for them. Austin designer Kristen Nix said multiple oversized pendants above an island can feel excessive, suggesting discreet flush mounts or a single pendant as alternatives.
Pot fillers drew criticism over their plumbing costs and usefulness. Nantucket designer Kathleen Hay questioned their value in a residential kitchen, while Chicago designer Tom Stringer said a faucet left unused for long periods can be unpleasant when it is eventually turned on. San Francisco Bay Area designer Cory Alisa Ferris also raised the possibility of damage if a pot filler leaks.
Other suggestions focus on materials and upkeep. Los Angeles designer Linda Hayslett said a statement backsplash behind a cooktop can date a kitchen and favored a continuous backsplash instead. New York designer Elizabeth Sesser objected to mural-style tiles because their imagery can be highly specific. Charlotte designer Nancy Parrish said open shelves require repeated organizing and cleaning because kitchen items collect dust and grease. Architect John Ike expressed a preference for analog appliance controls over touch screens and electronic faucets.
Kitchen ideas designers are ready to leave behind What to weigh before renovating
VERANDA shared designers’ preferences on kitchen features. Their views raise practical questions, but do not establish what works for every home.
Ideas drawing criticism
The available text describes several features designers would reconsider.
Double islands
They can interrupt circulation and may need more space than a home has.
Pot fillers
Designers questioned their plumbing costs, upkeep and everyday usefulness.
Statement backsplashes
Some designers prefer continuous surfaces over cooktop accents or specific mural imagery.
Open shelves
Exposed kitchen items can need repeated cleaning and organizing.
Trade-offs to consider
The concerns described focus on daily use, maintenance and personal taste.
- How the layout affects movement
- Added plumbing and possible leaks
- Cleaning exposed shelves
- Continuous backsplash materials
- Discreet or fewer island pendants
- Analog appliance controls
Before committing
Kitchen features can be costly to change, so consider how they fit your home and routine.
Assess circulation and whether the proposed layout suits the room.
Consider how often you will use a feature and what upkeep it needs.
Ask a designer or contractor about installation and maintenance.
Limits of the source
The supplied text does not include enough information to treat the list as a broad industry verdict.
- The number of designers and their selection method are not stated.
- The excerpt ends during its discussion of waterfall islands.
- The full list of 13 ideas and the article’s publication date are not provided.
Renovation Choices That Affect Daily Use
The list matters to homeowners because kitchen decisions can be expensive and difficult to reverse. Features such as extra plumbing, custom stonework and built-in cabinetry can involve costs beyond the visible finish, while layout choices affect how people move and work in the room. The designers’ comments offer considerations to weigh before committing, rather than a rulebook for renovation.
The source also frames the kitchen as a major investment and argues for personal, lasting design over a single fashionable look. That is the publication’s editorial position; the designer responses add specific examples of where trend-driven choices may conflict with maintenance, utility or a homeowner’s routine. A feature criticized by one designer may still suit another household’s space and needs.
Products Worth Considering

Levoit Eleva 300X Air Purifier with Fully Sealed HEPA Filtration and Smart Control

Philips Hue Play HDMI Sync Box 8K

Bose TV Speaker Compact Soundbar with Bluetooth and HDMI-ARC, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How VERANDA Gathered the Opinions
The article says the publication asked designers on its Trade Secrets newsletter to name kitchen ideas they were tired of seeing. VERANDA describes its own preference as timeless and distinctive design rather than relying heavily on one trend. It says it still covers new products and ideas when they meet its standards for design and quality.
The supplied source includes details for several entries, including double islands, over-island pendants, pot fillers, accent backsplashes, touch-activated appliances and open shelves. It begins its discussion of waterfall islands—stone counters that continue down the sides to the floor—but the available text cuts off before giving the designer’s reasoning or the rest of the 13-item list. The absent entries cannot be confirmed from the material provided.
“Double islands feel like they’re breaking up a kitchen in a way where I feel I am leapfrogging to get around in them.”
— Lisa Simopoulos, Northern California designer
What the Survey Cannot Establish
The source does not state how many designers responded, how they were selected, or whether the views represent the broader design industry. It also does not provide homeowner data on the cost, frequency of use or performance of the features discussed. The recommendations should be read as professional opinions, not evidence that a particular choice is universally impractical or out of fashion.
The supplied text ends during the waterfall-island section and does not include the full list of 13 ideas. It is therefore unclear what the remaining entries are or what arguments the article makes about them. The source also gives no publication date, so the timing of the survey and the opinions cannot be established from the material provided.
Questions to Ask Before Renovating
For readers planning a kitchen project, the next step is to test each proposed feature against available space, daily habits, maintenance and installation costs. A designer or contractor can help assess circulation and whether an added fixture or finish makes sense for the specific plan. The article supplies opinions to prompt that discussion; it does not announce a design standard or a change in building requirements.
A complete account of all 13 ideas would require the full VERANDA article, which is not included in the supplied material. Until that text is available, only the trends described above can be reported with confidence.
Key Questions
What kitchen ideas did the designers criticize?
The supplied text discusses double islands, multiple pendants over islands, pot fillers, accent or mural backsplashes, touch-activated appliances and open shelves. It also introduces waterfall islands, but cuts off before giving the full discussion.
Are these trends officially considered outdated?
No. These are opinions from designers surveyed by VERANDA, not an official industry determination or evidence that every homeowner should avoid the features.
Why did some designers object to pot fillers?
They questioned whether the convenience justifies additional plumbing and possible maintenance concerns. One designer also noted that a pot still has to be moved to the sink for draining.
What did the source say about open shelving?
Designer Nancy Parrish said open shelves can require frequent organizing and cleaning because their contents are exposed to dust and kitchen grease.
Does the source provide all 13 ideas?
No. The supplied excerpt stops partway through the waterfall-island discussion, so the remaining items and their explanations are not available here.
Source: veranda.com
